Should Our Mother with Dementia Move to a Care Home?

Should Our Mother with Dementia Move to a Care Home?

 

What do you do when a parent suffers from dementia and can no longer live alone? There’s no question that when parents grow old, sick, frail, or develop dementia, it is an extremely difficult and stressful situation for both the individuals and their families. Many family members push themselves to exhaustion and eventually fall ill themselves after often caring for years to the point of self-sacrifice.

 

At first, we didn’t even recognize our mother’s dementia. She hid and masked it very well. In hindsight, we can see that she had been engaging in an elaborate concealment for years, and we simply didn’t see through it due to a lack of experience. But that is also more than understandable, because it involves a great deal of shame and pain when individuals realize that their cognitive abilities are increasingly failing them. In the early stages, this is still quite obvious to those with dementia.

 

However, I don’t want to write too much about dementia itself; there is certainly plenty of literature on that. My conscious intention is to share the process, the depths we navigated through, and what the final decision was: should our mother go to a care home or not?

 

We realized our mother was suffering from dementia about a year before her husband retired. Until his retirement—which turned out not to be very peaceful at all—she managed quite well on her own during the day. Then her husband was home more, and over the course of the next three years, her cognitive abilities declined further. Soon, apart from hanging up and taking down laundry (her favorite pastime all her life), she couldn’t do anything truly meaningful anymore. Daily life with her was paved with many big and small challenges for her husband. In the summer of his third year of retirement, he was diagnosed with cancer. Just two years prior, his sister had passed away from cancer, and in that same summer, shortly after the diagnosis, his father passed away as well.

 

Up until then, her husband had taken over almost all of my mother’s care. Only once a week did a care service come by to help her shower. Suddenly, the prospect arose that he would be out of commission for weeks to undergo surgery and then spend another four weeks at an alternative cancer clinic for treatment. I should mention that my mother had been very focused and reliant on her partners throughout her entire life. Naturally, this was intensified even further by her illness. Her husband was the rock in the surf and her entire sense of security in a world she could no longer navigate!

 

There was an emotional rollercoaster when her husband, together with us children, planned his absence. My brother felt it was the right time to place our mother in a care home so she would have the chance to adjust. Her husband was truly overwhelmed and at his wit’s end, but couldn’t quite bring himself to make that decision yet. I was also undecided, so we looked into the option of bringing in so-called “24-hour in-home care.” In a lengthy consultation, we learned about the conditions: not only was it very expensive at around €2,600 per month, but the term “24-hour care” is also misleading! In reality, it involves five hours of work per day performed by this caregiver or housekeeping assistant. What counted as work and what didn’t was vague and not entirely clear. Time was running out, and we had to make a quick decision.

 

So we opted for the 24-hour care because we wanted to provide our mother with her familiar environment and ensure she could continue to be with her beloved dog. There was one week left while her husband was still at home to train the young care assistant from Romania. We never would have expected this solution to go so completely wrong! Our mother rejected the care assistant from the very first moment and was totally hostile toward her. It got to the point where the young woman became afraid that my mother might hurt her with a knife. I must say, my mother is truly not an aggressive person. However, she was very jealous and did everything to defend her territory (“this is my house!”). When her husband was in the hospital and she was alone with the assistant, she actually chased the care assistant out of the house in the afternoon. To resolve the situation, we had to take our mother to our place overnight. The placement agency reacted very quickly and arranged a replacement. This time, a 25-year-old Polish woman came to us. The chemistry was right, and my mother accepted her very well at first. But she still didn’t drop her territorial behavior and asked every day when the helper would finally leave. For example, she often wouldn’t allow the young Polish woman to turn on the heating, cook, and under no circumstances enter her bedroom. We family members were constantly on edge. It was extremely stressful for both our mother and us.

 

I have heard positive stories many times about how such 24-hour caregivers often work out very well. Unfortunately, that was not the case for us. When serious complications arose for my mother’s husband and we didn’t know if or how he would survive, we decided to look for a care home for her. Do I need to say that this was a difficult step? An emotional rollercoaster? The challenge was that we were under time pressure again, because the Polish helper—with whom things were going so-so—had to leave soon due to family matters. Since open spots in care homes are unfortunately not in endless supply, we were simply relieved that after calling 15 care homes, two had a vacancy. We were able to view both, and as is typical with available care home spots, you have to decide immediately because the facility naturally wants and needs to fill the vacancy as quickly as possible.

 

The positive thing was that we had a good feeling about both care homes. One was farther away and had a single room available. The other was very conveniently located for us, but only had a spot in a double room. Making the decision was difficult. What was the right choice? Would our mother manage in a double room, and would her roommate get along with her? After our experiences with the home care assistants, we felt unsettled. In the end, I think it was good that we had to decide quickly, because you can never be sure what is right or wrong anyway, and you might otherwise drag out such a decision endlessly.

 

We chose the care home in the convenient location for us. Much of what we saw there was very positive, and the facility director suggested we wait and see regarding the double room, noting that in her experience, it could turn out very well. And if it truly didn’t work out, we would be offered a single room in the foreseeable future. We still had a few days over the weekend until the move-in date. On the day we registered her, she said to me at home (without knowing anything about it) that maybe she would have to go to a care home soon after all…

 

That weekend was excruciating for us. We had consciously decided not to tell her beforehand, because by that point she was no longer able to process such things. On Monday morning, after the Polish caregiver had left, she said she didn’t want to stay alone in the house. At that point, we told her she could come with us to look at a care home. At first, she was very upset, saying we had planned everything behind her back and told her nothing—which was true. Then she agreed to simply go and take a look. The journey began.

 

Arrived at the care home, she initially put up total resistance. NOTHING suited her, and she was entirely certain “she definitely didn’t want to stay here.” In fact, the three of us spent five hours calmly talking to her until the staff said, “Now it’s time for dinner, and it’s the right moment for the family members to go home.” We left. Would she try to run away? The care facility staff cannot force anyone to stay; for that, you would need a court order due to self-harm or danger to others.

 

The next day, I visited her in the early afternoon. What would await me?! With very mixed feelings, I entered the nursing home and took the elevator to the first floor. My mother was sitting in the floor kitchen with two other residents and was overjoyed when she saw me. She was in a good mood, and we went to her room. There, I met her roommate for the first time—a mentally sharp 85-year-old woman who is unfortunately no longer physically robust. I had brought sweets, and we chatted for two hours until I announced that I was going home now. She was briefly confused and said she would have to come along then. I assured her she was in the best of hands here and disappeared into the elevator.

 

Over the next four weeks, we visited her daily in rotation. I was very glad that I could share the visits and all the organizational tasks with my brother and his wife. Our mother never tried to run away. However, she is a very cautious and anxious person and never made any attempts to wander off even when she was at home. For some people with dementia, the tendency to wander or roam becomes a problem when they feel unhappy in a care home and want to leave.

 

To our great surprise, our mother settled into the nursing home very quickly and, above all, very well. As early as the second or third day, she was talking about how nice it was here, how good the energy was, and how kind the people were. Yes, you could say she practically blossomed all over again. While she had withdrawn more and more over the last few years and—contrary to her lively, communicative nature—became quieter and quieter in conversations, she is now coming out of her shell again. She feels very comfortable and is as relaxed as she hasn’t been in a long time. The past few years she had been very anxious and restless. There is a conservatory on her floor with a very wide panoramic view. She likes this incredibly much, and she sits there very often, both alone and with us when we visit.

 

I am very glad we tried the 24-hour caregiver option. Otherwise, the thought that it might have been a good solution might have always gnawed at us. But in our case, the nursing home is truly the ideal solution. Her dementia is certainly very advanced, but not yet so far gone that she misses everything; rather, she is able to enjoy the benefits of a care home. What is positive for my mother:

  • She is never alone; someone is always nearby, both fellow residents and nursing staff. She had a fear of being alone her entire life.
  • Daily life is very clearly structured with fixed times for meals and activities. This is especially important for people with Alzheimer’s and does her an incredible amount of good.
  • She doesn’t have to take care of anything. In her own house, she felt heavily responsible for everything, but could no longer live up to that responsibility in any way, which caused her a great deal of stress.
  • Her belongings have shrunk to the essentials, meaning there is little to confuse her, and she doesn’t have to manage anything either.
  • She loves conversations with other residents, which now take place much more on her level. Previously, she was surrounded only by healthy, mentally sharp people, which always made her feel inferior and, as mentioned, made her quieter and quieter.
  • She really enjoys the program offered at the home.
  • She relishes receiving help and being looked after.
  • We are also much more relaxed because everything is running smoothly, and during our visits, we can focus entirely on her. At home, when the 24-hour caregiver was there, there was always a lot to do.
  • She likes the conservatory and the view there unbelievably much.

 

Every case is different, and what works well for us might be completely different in other situations! It was simply my concern to illustrate that a care home can also be a very good solution. Our mother’s predecessor—the woman who shared the room with the 85-year-old for three months before our mother moved in—also had dementia at a less advanced stage. She had been there for short-term care for three months and was then taken back home. However, she didn’t want to go home at all anymore! And an acquaintance also told us that her relative, who suffered from Alzheimer’s, blossomed in the care home just like our mother did.

 

Speaking of the dog: as I mentioned above, the small dog was our mother’s absolute world. To our complete astonishment, she immediately forgot about the dog entirely and never asked about it once. I never would have thought that possible.

 

It is and remains a very difficult, emotional decision that no one can take off your shoulders and where there is no universal solution. Everyone has to find the best solution for themselves and their loved one. One possibility, however, is to try out short-term care for three weeks. From Care Level 2 onward, health insurance covers a large portion of the costs. This allows everyone involved to experience firsthand for a clearly defined period how it works and whether it might also be a fitting choice for the future. Perhaps the results will be quite different than expected! We were surprised over and over again throughout this process, that much is certain!